The Tigers 2019 Payroll Is Indefensible

The Tigers opened Spring Training last week in Lakeland without having done much to improve on their 2018 campaign. This offseason they signed Matt Moore, Tyson Ross, Jordy Mercer, and the standard contingent of minor league free agents. Moore, Ross, and Mercer were all solid signings, as they all have the potential to reclaim some past glory and provide the Tigers with a nice little return on their investment. But the 2018 Tigers were not a team that needed tweaks to contend in 2019, they needed big upgrades.

The 2018 Tigers won 64 games, which is the same number of games they won during the 2017 season in which had the worst record in baseball. Now of course there is no way to guarantee a great season, or even a contending season, but the Tigers haven’t done anything this winter to even make an attempt at getting into the wild card or divisional race. That is especially odd given how little most of the other teams are doing to truly improve themselves.

What is going on?

Obviously the Tigers were in bad place in 2017 and trading away their good, aging veterans made tons of baseball sense. They were unlikely to win with the core they had assembled and rather than stumble through the next couple of years, they blew up the roster and turned Verlander, Martinez, Upton, et all into players who would help them win in the future. Trading now talent for future talent was a wise baseball move. The financial savings from getting Verlander off the books was relatively unimportant from a baseball perspective, but the long term talent wasn’t.

Going into 2018, there really wasn’t a way to build a winner through free agency given the roster they had. There were too many holes and not enough available players to make it a great short term move, and it certainly wouldn’t have made sense long term.

But 2019 is different. The current Tigers roster is probably assembled to win around 70 games, give or take. That’s not a great team at all, but there is a lot of room for growth and there are a lot of good players still available in February. Bryce Harper. Manny Machado. Dallas Keuchel. Craig Kimbrel. Marwin Gonzalez. These are potentially large upgrades for the Tigers this year, with many of them having the potential to be good for the next several seasons. This is to say nothing of the many players the team could pick up on one- or two-year deals to help bridge the gap (e.g. Adam Jones).

Why aren’t the Tigers making serious plays for at least some of these players?

It’s reasonable for the team to look at their current roster and think they probably can’t win the division in 2019 even with some major upgrades. But they can certainly sniff the wild card, and more importantly, the players they sign in 2019 will be on their team in 2020 and 2021 when their prospects start graduating. The Tigers shouldn’t sign a 34-year-old 1B/DH to five-year deal right now, but Harper and Machado are in their mid-20s. They will still be in their peak years in 2020, 2021, and 2022. And it’s not like the Tigers can pass on Harper this year, save the $35 million and then sign him next year. That’s not how it works.

The Tigers are also not in any kind of financial crunch. In 2018, they had the 20th highest payroll in the league at around $125 million. This was a stark contrast to the 10 previous seasons in which their payroll was in the top 10, including nine seasons in the top six. They had payrolls in the high $190M range in 2016 and 2017.

Clearly, a major difference is that Mike Ilitch died and his son is now running the team. Chris Ilitch isn’t trying to win a World Series as urgently, which makes sense given that he’s not in his 80s hoping for one last taste of glory. I get that Chris Ilitch isn’t going to push Avila to mortgage the future and spend like there is no tomorrow, but he’s used that cover, the cover of the 2017 rebuild, and the fact that the rest of the league is pretending they can’t afford free agents to completely avoid investing in the team. The Tigers payroll in 2019 might end up being less than it was in 2018, and even if it’s higher it will be roughly in the same place.

There is no justification for that. The Tigers were financially capable of handling payrolls near $200 million a couple of years ago. The fact that they aren’t even close to that is indefensible. The league as a whole is making tons of money, the Tigers are closing in on a new TV deal (either with Fox or their own RSN), and the Ilitch family shows no signs of being in a difficult financial situation. The Tigers aren’t spending money right now because they don’t want to, and the only reason they don’t want to is because the ownership group would prefer to have higher profits.

Put another way, there is no baseball reason why the Tigers shouldn’t be out there trying to sign some of these marquee free agents. It would be one thing if every player had a bidding war going and the Tigers decided they didn’t want to overpay for Harper or Machado given that they probably aren’t going to get a ton of value out of the 2019 version, so a team like the Yankees might be able to spend more. But that’s not even the case. The Tigers could get these guys for less than they’re actually worth and they don’t appear to be trying.

They have room on the balance sheet, they need big upgrades, and they are in the market for a new generation of stars to carry the marketing side of the organization. Harper could be with the organization for a decade, selling merchandise and earning a spot on the brick wall, but the Tigers appear content to give that up so that the Ilitches can…have more money?

The Tigers could be a lot better in 2019 if they went out and signed free agents, but much more importantly, they could set themselves up for real greatness in 2020 to 2022 if they acquire building block players right now who will be there when Mize, Manning, Paredes, and Perez coming knocking.

There is still time. We are in the midst of a league-wide cheapskate crisis, meaning that there are great players still available on the market in mid-February. If the Tigers want to build a winner now and into the near future, the path to return to the top of the Central is wide open. All it will take is spending money that they have. It will cost them nothing in prospect talent. Going into 2019 spending less than $130 million on the big league roster is a joke for an organization with the history and resources of the Tigers. The fans in Detroit want a winner and the leadership of the team isn’t even pretending like they care.

Mike Ilitch sometimes overspent on big name veterans, occasionally to his detriment. But you can bet if he had a change to sign generational talents at age 26, he wouldn’t be sitting on his hands talking about payroll flexibility and rebuilding. Mike Ilitch would have spent the money because Mike Ilitch wanted to win as desperately as any owner in recent memory. There is still time his successor to follow that example.


7 responses

  1. Serious flaws in this thinking. First, these players out there will want opt outs to the contracts after a year or two to re-test the market. That doesn’t help the tigers in 2022 and beyond. The FA’s will also want above market pricing to go to a team that isn’t a playoff team. You may suggest a Wild Card, but with teams like the Red Sox, Yankees, Rays, Indians, Astros, and A’s all much better, a very small shot to make a wild card spot. You speak of past years of spending, but that was under Mike Illitch who went into his own pockets to fund the business. The Trust that owns the Tigers now run it like a business, not a fantasy team. The Tigers do not have a good core of players to build on and don’t have a rotation that has shown it is even league average. One new starter will not help it get there. You have to also realize Illitch was robbing from the Player development side to fund his free agent bonanza and new leadership is making a more balanced spending plan for a team in this market. The Disney/Fox deal means they will need to sell off the regional sports channels and it could be a very different owner. MLB is trying to acquire these as well as Sinclair. Yeah, those guys. I doubt you get a great deal with them. Last, with an uncertain future with MLBPA, not the time to be manipulated into buying free agents like Mike Illitch was.

  2. A very one-sided viewpoint. Signing any one of Machado, Harper, Keuchel. Kimbrel. or Gonzalez will most likely NOT make the Tigers a potential wild-card contender this year or next year. All it would do is limit the amount of money available after 2020. Moreover, the writing is on the wall that there may be a prolonged strike after 2021 due to the players not understanding the current market and crying ‘collusion’. Indeed, while there have been recent studies conducted over the past few years that seem to suggest a player is worth approximately $10m per WAR (ie, a 3-WAR player worth $30m) ..those are not necessarily actual worth because those could reflect overly inflated valuations. Futhermore, by its very nature the metric called “WAR” is merely Wins Above Replacement value ..which means a 3-War player could be counted upon to produce 3 more wins for the franchise in any given year. So realistically, a 3-WAR player could turn an 81-81 team into an 84-78 team. Notice that the “Win” factor does not factor in the actual Return on Investment for the owner of the franchise. .. On the other hand, baseball owners tend to be among the richest people in America and very astute about how they ‘invest’ their revenues. More recent studies suggest that each additional “Win” will actually translate into an approximate increase in profits of ‘only’ $1.5m for the franchise. .. .. .. .. So basically, team owners are looking at the bottom line more now than they may have in the past. Owners such as George Steinbrenner and Mike Ilitch spent some of their own money to sign FA’s to huge unsustainable contracts. Owners are now hiring Harvard-type grads to oversee their spending. Hopefully the Tigers are fully committed to making good sound business decisions that might ensure competitive teams for the next 2 decades beginning in about 2024 (when Miggy’s contract is done.)

  3. I agree with your overall assessment. In particular, someone like Merwin Gonzalez would be great–not too expensive, a good role model, has been on a playoff-winning team, has a lot of versatility, and just an all-around good baseball player. Plus, the Tigers don’t have e.g. the Padres’ farm system, so help is going to have to come from somewhere in the next few years.

  4. […] made clear that they do not even intend to build a winner until 2021 (even though, as I’ve argued, they could build one more […]

  5. […] offseason to assemble a reasonably competitive bunch. But going into 2019, the Tigers absolutely could have improved the roster and made this year’s team watchable. Would they have won enough games to take the […]

  6. […] put together a good product in 2018. They tanked in kind of an off-putting way in 2019 because they could have put together a better product without sacrificing the future and they simply chose not to for the benefit of Ilitch Holdings. Going into 2020, it didn’t […]

  7. Great post thank yyou

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: