With the All-Star rosters looming ahead this weekend, New English D weighs into the fray with these picks. We covered the AL yesterday. A few notes up front. First, I’ve conformed the roster size to the official requirements and have selected starters I feel are most deserving based on their 2013 seasons and have given no deference to the voting up through this point. My view is that the All-Star Game should showcase the game’s standout performers from the first half of 2013, not the best players over the last year or the best players by talent even if they haven’t performed. I think the game should highlight the players who play well, not the players MLB thinks are “marketable.” Every team is represented and I’ve given a list of players who are the first replacements for injuries and such. As you know, this site appreciates advanced statistics, so should you choose to comment on these selections, please do so without using “RBI” or “Wins.” Finally, I watch a ton of baseball, but I watch fewer NL games by function of being a Tigers fan, so some of the down ballot selections are a bit less sure footed.
And I just couldn’t leave Puig out. He has to play in this game.
PLAYER | TEAM | POSITION |
Yadier Molina | Cardinals | C |
Joey Votto | Reds | 1B |
Matt Carpenter | Cardinals | 2B |
Jean Segura | Brewers | SS |
David Wright | Mets | 3B |
Carlos Gomez | Brewers | OF |
Andrew McCutchen | Pirates | OF |
Carlos Gonzalez | Rockies | OF |
Buster Posey | Giants | DH |
Matt Harvey | Mets | SP |
Russell Martin | Pirates | C |
Paul Goldschmidt | Dbacks | 1B |
Allen Craig | Cardinals | 1B |
Chase Utley | Phillies | 2B |
Ian Desmond | Nationals | SS |
Pedro Alvarez | Pirates | 3B |
Starling Marte | Pirates | OF |
Bryce Harper | Nationals | OF |
Shin Soo Choo | Reds | OF |
Yasiel Puig | Dodgers | OF |
Michael Cuddyer | Rockies | OF |
Todd Frazier | Reds | 3B |
Adam Wainwright | Cardinals | SP |
Cliff Lee | Phillies | SP |
Clayton Kershaw | Dodgers | SP |
Homer Bailey | Reds | SP |
Mat Latos | Reds | SP |
Jeff Samardzija | Cubs | SP |
Jordan Zimmermann | Nationals | SP |
Jose Fernandez | Marlins | SP |
Craig Kimbrel | Braves | RP |
Sergio Romo | Giants | RP |
Mark Melancon | Pirates | RP |
Jason Grilli | Pirates | RP |
Ryan Braun* | Brewers | OF |
Troy Tulowitzki* | Rockies | SS |
Evereth Cabrera* | Padres | SS |
FIRST REPLACEMENTS | ||
Jhoulys Chacin | Rockies | SP |
Patrick Corbin | Dbacks | SP |
Shelby Miller | Cardinals | SP |
Stephen Strasburg | Nationals | SP |
Chris Johnson | Braves | 3B |
Carlos Beltran | Cardinals | OF |
Dominic Brown | Phillies | OF |
* INJURED |
[…] As usual, most of the roster is right, and it’s messed up at the margins. Here are my AL and NL picks and here are the full […]